‘Metropolis for All?’ public artwork pageant questions who builds our cities, and for whom


Gender-inclusive social design carries super potential (and duty) for bettering the dwelling, functioning and respiration cloth of cities, and in flip, the individuals who inhabit and make them. Secure neighbourhoods equate to psychological well being stability, which ends up in the conditioning of the residents who’re capable of function higher, lead balanced lives, give again to society in wellness, and make knowledgeable choices that aren’t compromised due to threats to security, well being or financial circumstances. A detailed-knit social realm, with entry to amenities, mobility, and correct illustration, no matter gender, age, or occupation, can present a sense of help, and a way of belonging, that’s crucial for a society to flourish as a cohesive, well-oiled system.

Metropolis for All? was a public artwork pageant held over March-June, 2022 as a part of the Indo-French pageant Bonjour India, that questioned and mentioned the function of gender, amongst different elements, in shaping public areas and concrete experiences. It additionally travelled to the French metropolis of Lyon to create a cross-cultural dialogue between the 2 nations. Designed and curated by Indian architect Swati Janu (Founder, Social Design Collaborative) and French social anthropologist Chris Blache (Founder, Style et Ville), it was organised by the French Institute in India and the Alliance Francaise community to journey throughout 6 Indian cities – Jaipur, Chandigarh, Ahmedabad, Pune, Bengaluru and Delhi – participating on-line and on-ground with various communities, and asking a necessary query – who builds our cities and for whom?




Emblem of the travelling public artwork pageant, Metropolis for All? Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


STIR spoke with Janu in regards to the travelling public artwork pageant, stitching collectively social design and the citizen well being of those chosen cities, Metropolis for All? raises questions for on the much-needed discourse about equality, and the way now, greater than ever, it is very important elevate and tackle these inquiries in as a lot capability as attainable.

Jincy Iype: What are some insights gathered from Metropolis for All?.

Swati Janu: The three-month-long challenge encompassed on-street discussions on the neighbourhood stage, in addition to public exhibitions on the metropolis stage, throughout chosen cities in India and France. Via the neighbourhood-level discussions, city-level patterns emerged, concerning how we navigate in our cities, and what probably the most inclusive areas had been for all. Connaught Place and India Gate are recognized to be such locations in Delhi, whereas in Bengaluru, it turned out to be their gardens, Lal Bagh and Cubbon Park. In Chandigarh, it was Lake Sukhna and in Ahmedabad, Lake Kankaria and the riverfront emerged unanimous, to be probably the most frequented public areas by folks of all backgrounds.



Some activities carried out as part of the initiative included interactive mapping at a neighbourhood level across each city to understand people’s relationships with their respective cities | City for All? | STIRworld
Some actions carried out as a part of the initiative included interactive mapping at a neighbourhood stage throughout every metropolis to grasp folks’s relationships with their respective cities Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


Via these interactions, folks started sharing their gendered experiences in addition to the obstacles confronted of their mobility and security, bodily, social and financial. In Jaipur, most ladies shared that non secular areas had been their favoured public area since that’s one place they really feel they’re “allowed” to go to, slightly than, say, a mall. Bengaluru residents felt that their metropolis was safer than most Indian ones, however remains to be vulnerable to late-night crime as a result of absence of “eyes on the road” in its city design. Ahmedabad, however, enjoys a vibrant nightlife as a result of its wealthy tradition of road meals and distributors who stay true place makers of public area in every metropolis, particularly in India.

Transgender individuals spoke of the extreme want for fundamental public infrastructure comparable to bathrooms for them as a result of many have needed to battle for this. There may be additionally a have to appropriately symbolize their identification, by way of easy steps that planning authorities can take comparable to allocating them area on public transport or rethinking public signage, sometimes seen solely by way of the binary gender lens of female and male. They shared experiences of being excluded from public areas comparable to malls or being denied entry to magnificence parlours as a result of their gender, despite the third gender being recognised by the Indian Structure since 2014. Many spoke about how, regardless of the upper prices, they like taking cabs or autos as an alternative of travelling by public transport which exposes them to day by day harassment by males or stigmatisation by girls. Binary, that’s, male or feminine strains for frisking in Delhi metro stations or the binary nature of seating in buses in Bengaluru additionally results in their discrimination when they’re compelled to suit into these areas.



City for All? exhibition in Ahmedabad, India was held in an old city chowk | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? exhibition in Ahmedabad, India was held in an previous metropolis chowk Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


Jincy: How has the attendance and response been to the initiative? How has data been documented, and extra importantly, what occurs to the information collected?

Swati: The weekend exhibitions in every metropolis had been held in central and open-to-all, public venues. Via place-making, on a regular basis public areas comparable to an underpass in Chandigarh, a pavement in Pune, a chowk in Ahmedabad, a walkway underneath a metro line in Bengaluru and courtyards of cultural areas in Delhi and Jaipur had been remodeled into vibrant pageant areas. Individuals from all walks of life got here collectively to take part within the discourse generated as a part of the challenge, in addition to within the cultural performances and art work put up by native artists. Whereas the general public areas such because the underpass and pavement noticed a gentle stream of holiday makers who heard of the occasion or curious passersby who simply dropped by, at Jawahar Kala Kendra and Bikaner Home in Delhi, we obtained an awesome response, with folks of all ages and talents exhibiting up. So many younger guests, particularly college students got here as much as us to share how grateful they had been for such an area, for kindling conversations which in any other case they’re unable to have in public.



City for All? exhibition in Delhi held at the Bikaner House | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? exhibition in Delhi held on the Bikaner Home Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


All of the 36 maps with residents’ votes of their favourite public area from the neighborhoods of the 6 Indian cities had been lastly displayed in Delhi in addition to Lyon in France, over Might and June of this 12 months. These have since been digitised, and are actually out there on Social Design Collaborative’s web site within the Open-Supply part. An essential consequence of the challenge has been a graphic novel by the Leewardists who compiled the learnings from the challenge within the type of an inventive narrative for college students of design and structure throughout India and France. Via the challenge, in addition they launched a zine (or a booklet) on what function gender performs in metropolis design and our day by day city experiences, and one other one questioning the binary method to metropolis planning in addition to in our mindsets, in collaboration with our studio and the Mist LGBTQ Basis.

Jincy: As a collaborative challenge between India and France, in what methods has Metropolis for All? strengthened ties between the 2 nations? What’s the worth of participatory tasks comparable to this in constructing cross-country collaborations?

Swati: The start line of this collaboration has been that gender inequality or gender-based discrimination is not only an issue particular to a rustic or metropolis, however a systemic problem for which all of us want to seek out collective options collectively.



People gathered beneath an underpass in Chandigarh for the City for All? exhibition in the city | City for All? | STIRworld
Individuals gathered beneath an underpass in Chandigarh for the Metropolis for All? exhibition within the metropolis Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


Bonjour India is a pageant meant for cross-cultural change and this 12 months, it turned an awesome platform for collective dialogue on gender inclusion by way of metropolis design. This Indo-French collaborative challenge helped create public discourse by way of on-line pupil workshops in addition to in-person exchanges when the challenge travelled from India to France, additionally taking with it the work of rising Indian artists comparable to Thunder Medusa and collectives comparable to Dalit Queer Mission.

Individuals realised how comparable we’re, and what we will study from one another by way of these endeavours with a typical purpose. I used to be glad to seek out that the Mayor of 1er arrondissement is already taking lively steps towards gender inclusion by way of her latest initiatives like renaming public areas and streets in Lyon after girls. That’s certainly a small, however highly effective step in the direction of the celebration of the identification and recognition of the contribution of girls, transgender and non-binary folks through the years. What number of streets in our metropolis do we all know of that aren’t named after males?



City for All? on ground engagement in Jaipur and Chandigarh, India | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? on floor engagement in Jaipur and Chandigarh, India Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


France too has rather a lot to study from India’s traditionally recognised method to transgender and intersex folks, particularly inside the Hijra group, regardless that it’s not with out its personal set of challenges and exploitation. In direction of this, in Bengaluru and Lyon, the challenge screened the documentary movie Kathegala Kanive directed by Vikas Badiger, the founding father of Faces of Bengaluru, to speak in regards to the experiences of hijras in Bengaluru from their very own perspective.

Jincy: What are you able to inform us in regards to the collaboration with Chris Blache, Institut Francais and Alliance Française? 

Swati: Chris and I’ve recognized one another’s work for a couple of years now however that is the primary time we had the possibility to work so carefully. The collaboration along with her organisation Style et Ville (Gender and Metropolis) has been on the coronary heart of this initiative as she brings a long time of expertise. Aside from being an anthropologist, she is an activist who has been integral to French radical collectives comparable to La Barbe. She has helped a number of cities in gender mainstreaming their method over the previous years, in addition to gender-sensitive budgeting, and her steerage shaped the thrust of all our efforts.



City for All? on ground engagement in Ahmedabad and Pune, India | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? on floor engagement in Ahmedabad and Pune, India Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


The French Institute in India and Alliance Francaise community have lengthy been dedicated to equality and freedom of speech by way of arts and science. I’m glad for his or her help and the unimaginable efforts of their groups in every metropolis. To not overlook, the spine of this challenge has been the collaboration with native companions and universities in every metropolis, and the involvement of scholars of design and structure. In Chandigarh, college students of Chitkara College engaged the general public on floor, whereas in Pune, the scholars of PVP-COA themselves constructed and arrange the exhibition as a part of their course curriculum.

Jincy: Aside from the inquiries raised by the pageant at its onset, what are some questions that got here up from the members themselves, over the course of the challenge?

Swati: For many guests, an understanding of transgender and non-binary folks was utterly new. There have been a number of harmless questions by younger and previous, on how gender could possibly be seen as a spectrum, exterior of the heteronormative method of seeing it as simply binary. Probably the greatest varieties of suggestions I obtained was that many felt that the exhibitions felt like secure areas for them to ask questions, with out inhibitions or judgements.

One other frequent query that popped up typically was the extent of the function design has, in addressing gender inequality, contemplating that it’s a deeply systemic and social problem. This can be a legitimate query, as we don’t realise the tangible methods we will result in inclusion in each area. However the second we began exhibiting them examples of gender-sensitive designs from public transport to bathrooms, they understood the worth and the target of the challenge instantly. Private narratives shared by members additional helped the guests perceive challenges confronted by somebody as a result of their gender or sexuality which we in any other case may by no means have thought of.



City for All? on ground engagement in Bengaluru and Delhi, India | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? on floor engagement in Bengaluru and Delhi, India Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


Jincy: Many who don’t fall underneath the meant viewers charted out by Metropolis for All? appear to imagine that they’ve full company on the addressed points and that these may not be as severe as they’re projected – how can they be made conscious of how dire the state of affairs really is, and the way they’ve a key function to play in relation to making an precise distinction for a wholesome, functioning society?

Swati: I’d say that everybody is the meant viewers – from my grandmother to your neighbour to the mayor. That’s the reason the challenge has taken a twin method – that of a convivial public artwork pageant in addition to that which is asking questions on the stage of coverage and governance. It turned supremely essential to mainstream the discourse on gender and sexuality by inviting public officers to every exhibition’s opening occasion from the Chief Secretary of Rajasthan who spoke in regards to the want for useful bathrooms for girls to the native Corporator of Pune who addressed the necessity for amenities catering to transgender folks. A dialogue on the necessity for integrating data on transgender individuals within the faculty syllabus was additionally held with the Schooling Minister of Gujarat, serving to pave the best way for hopefully, long-term change.

Jincy: What had been some workable options that got here out of the train? Can these be put into observe with speedy impact and can they elicit outcomes?

Swati: Long run change is sluggish and complicated, and positively not attainable in a single day. Nevertheless, I wish to suppose that the challenge helped push the dialogue ahead, in the direction of creating inclusive and equal amenities and luxury for all genders.

A number of the actionable steps that emerged from the discussions had been making certain sufficient bathrooms for transgender folks in public areas, universities and workplaces. After all, the rights of transgender folks have to transcend simply the allocation of bathrooms to problems with identification and illustration as nicely. Making certain extra gender-neutral or gender-equal signage on streets and public amenities is one other method ahead. Lyon has already taken the step to start out renaming its streets after girls and non-binary folks. Can different cities observe?



City for All? post travelling across 6 Indian cities culminated in Lyon, France, where the team interacted with people in the well-known and central public space Place des Terreaux | City for All? | STIRworld
Metropolis for All? submit travelling throughout 6 Indian cities culminated in Lyon, France, the place the group interacted with folks within the well-known and central public area Place des Terreaux Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


One other essential step a few of us in management positions can take is hiring transgender individuals who proceed to face discrimination as a result of their gender and are unable to seek out jobs. In Karnataka, the federal government has just lately introduced a one% reservation within the authorities companies for transgender folks. Can different states take comparable steps?

Whereas Bengaluru is seen as a way more progressive metropolis as compared, with numerous girls within the IT business, solely a mere 4% of board rooms have girls in them. Areas of energy and visibility are to this present day, occupied predominantly by males. Can we start to alter that by creating extra range in our workplaces, particularly on the high? What about areas of visibility comparable to panel discussions or options in magazines? We’d not have “manels” if extra males refused to be part of panels until there’s a truthful illustration of genders. These are some steps we will instantly begin taking in our areas of affect.

The challenge has engaged deeply with architectural and design college students and it’s my hope that they’ll take the learnings ahead of their skilled expertise as nicely. I strongly imagine that until now we have range inside our planning and design workplaces, we can not create inclusive public areas and cities.



The mayor involved in mapping activity (L); priests gathering to interact with the mapping initiative in Lyon (R) | City for All? | STIRworld
The mayor concerned in mapping exercise (L); clergymen gathering to work together with the mapping initiative in Lyon (R) Picture: Courtesy of Social Design Collaborative


Jincy: What have been some takeaways from the culminating exhibition in Lyon, France?

Swati: In Lyon, we interacted with folks within the well-known and central public area Place des Terreaux and realised that there are extra similarities than variations between Indian and French cities. Non-binary and transgender youth shared their day by day challenges from road harassment to transphobia in society. The necessity for accessibility in public areas was one other problem that got here up by way of the interactive actions. The exhibition was put up on the Maison de l’Structure with a public dialogue on the city corridor of Mairie du 1er arrondissement.

The most important takeaway for me has been the significance of public areas as crucibles of integration inside French cities, from swimming swimming pools to libraries to public colleges which deliver collectively folks from various backgrounds. The extra such areas we create, for socio-economic integration, the extra understanding and empathy garnered between totally different teams. That is as a lot relevant to Indian cities as it’s to French. It additional helps to create public occasions and artwork festivals in these areas to deliver folks collectively on essential points by way of placemaking, tradition and dialogue.



Supply hyperlink